«You cannot prove anything by crossing from another kind – e.g. something geometrical by arithmetic. There are three things involved in demonstration: one, what is being demonstrated, or the conclusion (this is what holds of some kind in itself); one, the axioms (axioms are the items from which the demonstrations proceed); third, the underlying kind whose attributes – i.e. the items incidental to it in itself – the demonstrations make plain» (Aristotle, Posterior Analytics 75a38-b2). However, Aristotle accepts an exception: the case of the sciences having a hierarchical relationship, such that one falls under the other. In this case it is possible to prove by crossing from another kind. Throughout Posterior Analytics Aristotle presents several examples of sciences having this relationship. My goal is to analyse such examples in order to show the importance and coherence of the Aristotelian theory of the hierarchy of sciences.

(2019). Aristote et la hiérarchie des sciences [journal article - articolo]. In RIVISTA DI FILOSOFIA NEOSCOLASTICA. Retrieved from http://hdl.handle.net/10446/152795

Aristote et la hiérarchie des sciences

Bonelli, Maddalena
2019-01-01

Abstract

«You cannot prove anything by crossing from another kind – e.g. something geometrical by arithmetic. There are three things involved in demonstration: one, what is being demonstrated, or the conclusion (this is what holds of some kind in itself); one, the axioms (axioms are the items from which the demonstrations proceed); third, the underlying kind whose attributes – i.e. the items incidental to it in itself – the demonstrations make plain» (Aristotle, Posterior Analytics 75a38-b2). However, Aristotle accepts an exception: the case of the sciences having a hierarchical relationship, such that one falls under the other. In this case it is possible to prove by crossing from another kind. Throughout Posterior Analytics Aristotle presents several examples of sciences having this relationship. My goal is to analyse such examples in order to show the importance and coherence of the Aristotelian theory of the hierarchy of sciences.
articolo
2019
Bonelli, Maddalena
(2019). Aristote et la hiérarchie des sciences [journal article - articolo]. In RIVISTA DI FILOSOFIA NEOSCOLASTICA. Retrieved from http://hdl.handle.net/10446/152795
File allegato/i alla scheda:
File Dimensione del file Formato  
hiérarchieDEF.pdf

Solo gestori di archivio

Versione: publisher's version - versione editoriale
Licenza: Licenza default Aisberg
Dimensione del file 337.34 kB
Formato Adobe PDF
337.34 kB Adobe PDF   Visualizza/Apri
Pubblicazioni consigliate

Aisberg ©2008 Servizi bibliotecari, Università degli studi di Bergamo | Terms of use/Condizioni di utilizzo

Utilizza questo identificativo per citare o creare un link a questo documento: https://hdl.handle.net/10446/152795
Citazioni
  • Scopus ND
  • ???jsp.display-item.citation.isi??? 0
social impact