The Covid-19 pandemic offers an unprecedented opportunity to investigate knowledge-making practices and associated epistemic conflicts. In addition to the conflict between the scientific community and social groups that opposed controversial positions, we argue that the pandemic has been the backdrop of a less visible ‘epistemic war’ within the medical field, as the radical uncertainty paved the way to challenge the postulated universality of the hierarchy of evidence underlying Evidence-Based Medicine. Given this background, the study focused on the emergence of several physicians’ networks providing home treatment in the early stages of SARS-CoV-2 infection in Italy. Such communities of practices produced and shared knowledge and, in some cases, sought external legitimacy from the scientific community, policymakers and public opinion, thus acting as an epistemic community and coming into conflict with dominant epistemic agencies. In this ‘low-intensity epistemic war’, disputants intended to reaffirm or challenge the balance between the parties and not to annihilate the other side. By focusing on different epistemologies and practices in contemporary medicine, this study offers a more articulated and nuanced framework in which the claim of what is ‘true’ is shaped in a broader set of professional relations, ongoing scientific debates, and epistemic and political institutions

(2023). Low-intensity epistemic war. Medical communities and the development of legitimate knowledge in times of radical uncertainty [journal article - articolo]. In RASSEGNA ITALIANA DI SOCIOLOGIA. Retrieved from https://hdl.handle.net/10446/265989

Low-intensity epistemic war. Medical communities and the development of legitimate knowledge in times of radical uncertainty

Lusardi, Roberto;
2023-01-01

Abstract

The Covid-19 pandemic offers an unprecedented opportunity to investigate knowledge-making practices and associated epistemic conflicts. In addition to the conflict between the scientific community and social groups that opposed controversial positions, we argue that the pandemic has been the backdrop of a less visible ‘epistemic war’ within the medical field, as the radical uncertainty paved the way to challenge the postulated universality of the hierarchy of evidence underlying Evidence-Based Medicine. Given this background, the study focused on the emergence of several physicians’ networks providing home treatment in the early stages of SARS-CoV-2 infection in Italy. Such communities of practices produced and shared knowledge and, in some cases, sought external legitimacy from the scientific community, policymakers and public opinion, thus acting as an epistemic community and coming into conflict with dominant epistemic agencies. In this ‘low-intensity epistemic war’, disputants intended to reaffirm or challenge the balance between the parties and not to annihilate the other side. By focusing on different epistemologies and practices in contemporary medicine, this study offers a more articulated and nuanced framework in which the claim of what is ‘true’ is shaped in a broader set of professional relations, ongoing scientific debates, and epistemic and political institutions
articolo
2023
Lusardi, Roberto; Bronzini, Micol; Piras, Enrico Maria
(2023). Low-intensity epistemic war. Medical communities and the development of legitimate knowledge in times of radical uncertainty [journal article - articolo]. In RASSEGNA ITALIANA DI SOCIOLOGIA. Retrieved from https://hdl.handle.net/10446/265989
File allegato/i alla scheda:
File Dimensione del file Formato  
LusBroPir2023.pdf

Solo gestori di archivio

Versione: publisher's version - versione editoriale
Licenza: Licenza default Aisberg
Dimensione del file 498.85 kB
Formato Adobe PDF
498.85 kB Adobe PDF   Visualizza/Apri
Pubblicazioni consigliate

Aisberg ©2008 Servizi bibliotecari, Università degli studi di Bergamo | Terms of use/Condizioni di utilizzo

Utilizza questo identificativo per citare o creare un link a questo documento: https://hdl.handle.net/10446/265989
Citazioni
  • Scopus 0
  • ???jsp.display-item.citation.isi??? ND
social impact